Is insurance halal or Haram? This question has been debated by many Islamic scholars, and many Australian Muslims wonder how it relates to their lives.
Insurance is an integral part of Australian life. However, Muslims must be certain that they are able to accept this option without losing their core beliefs and values.
This article provides a balanced, fact-based analysis of whether insurance is halal or haram. This article will discuss all major Islamic concepts that are related to this topic, including takaful and riba as well as gharar and maysir. Let’s begin!
Table of Contents
What is Halal or Haram?
The term halal means “lawful,” while haram means “forbidden.” In Islam, halal is defined by the Shariah law, which has been passed down from the prophet Muhammad through the generations. According to Shariah, there are specific ways that animals must be slaughtered. The term halal applies to all forms of slaughtering of animals, including those using gas, electric, or sharp tools. Animals that have been slaughtered according to halal guidelines are considered halal meat. Halal animals include sheep, cattle, goats, swine, birds, and fish.
The Key Concepts
Before we can address the huge question of whether Muslim insurance is halal or haram, it’s important to first understand the main concepts. The key terms for insurance that might be considered haram are riba and gharar.
These concepts will be discussed first before we move on to takaful which is an Islamic concept used more often in the argument that insurance should be considered halal.
Read More: Scare insurance adjusters with these tips
Riba
The English translation of the concept of riba is interesting. It is also sometimes referred to as usury. It is basically a loan of money that is repaid later with a higher amount.
The concept of acquiring interests is clearly stated in the Koran: It is haram.
Riba is clearly prohibited under Islamic law. However, the question of whether insurance actually constitutes interest is another. To answer this question, however, we must examine other concepts.
This question is difficult to answer. It all depends on what type of insurance is used, and how well you understand the financial structure of insurance. We will be back shortly.
Gharar
Gharar, an Islamic concept, refers to the English concepts of uncertainty, deception, and risk. It comes from the hadiths, not the Koran.
Insurance is a form of uncertainty. It’s easy to see why. You are taking out insurance for a car, home, or business because you don’t know what future risks might affect them.
Gharar is prohibited under Islamic law as Muslims are expected to conduct honest and open business transactions. Gharar used to be used to prohibit activities like selling crops not yet harvested or animals not yet born.
This concept can be summarized in the words Abd al-Aziz ibn Baz (an Islamic scholar of the 20th century) who stated: “Do not sell what you don’t have.”
These transactions are prohibited by Islam because they could lead to aggrieved parties. A calf might become ill or die within days of its birth.
Like with riba, the application of this Islamic concept in modern insurance isn’t entirely clear.
Maysir
Maysir is the English term for gambling. It is however more general than The concept of qimar which directly relates to games of chance.
Maysir, as a term used to describe someone who gains benefit without exerting any effort, is forbidden by Islamic law. Feel Jamaldeen, a Muslim scholar, defines Maysir to be “the acquisition of wealth by chance (not through effort).”
The Koran (5.90-91) explains why Maysir should be forbidden. It is listed here with alcohol as haram because they ‘arouse hatred and discord among you and ‘deter from the mentions of God and prayer.
The second meaning is less relevant for the practice of selling and buying insurance. The first reason is not clear. Insurance does not necessarily represent wealth acquisition, but the restoration of something that has already been lost.
Takaful
Takaful, an Islamic concept, provides support for insurance models at a minimum. Takaful can roughly be translated as “solidarity” in English. It has a more specific meaning when used in the context of Islamic law.
Takaful is the idea that community members contribute to a common fund which can then be used to reimburse community members who have suffered some loss. The group might pay for a member’s house to be rebuilt after it is damaged in a fire.
This is why takaful, an Islamic form of insurance, is considered halal.
Both the Koran and the hadiths contain the scriptural basis for takaful. The Quran’s verse 5:2 contains the following instruction: “And cooperate in righteousness, piety, and sin, but not in aggression.
The moral foundation of takaful lies in community cooperation. This includes the underlying principles of charity and compassion.
Arguments for and against
These concepts will help us to understand the bigger question of whether insurance is halal or haram. We will summarize the arguments on both sides of this debate.
Insurers who have been in business for many years are likely to have a lot of experience in the field. They have spent years learning all aspects of the insurance industry, from how to calculate risk to how to handle a claim. They know how to price the product, and even if they don’t know anything about Sharia law, they are unlikely to knowingly commit a sin.
The Haram Argument
The haram side is the clear scripture and scholarly instruction that modern insurance practices constitute haram. Insurance implies some type of usury (riba), uncertainty, and gambling (maysir).
Even though the Islamic scriptures do not directly address modern financial practices, the argument against insurance is grounded on broader moral principles.
Many financial institutions might offer insurance products that are haram. Therefore, Muslims need to investigate these types of products and make informed judgments about their specifics.
Muslims, in particular, should carefully consider the purpose of these insurance contracts.
These insurance products are based on the assumption that one person can make a profit by selling other people’s insurance. Are these companies willing to risk the fortunes and success of their customers? What honesty are these companies when it comes to offering insurance?
Many modern financial institutions will answer these questions and conclude that the product being sold is haram.
The Halal Argument
One perspective could argue that an individual who pays for insurance isn’t violating any of the above-mentioned moral principles. Their intention to purchase insurance could be to protect their family. They don’t want to gain wealth but to protect against unforeseeable loss.
For those products which adhere to the takaful principle, insurance can be considered halal.
It is important to work with organizations that are truly community-oriented if Muslims want to ensure they make halal financial choices. These organizations will not try to make undue profits but be transparent and honest in all their dealings.
They should have the primary purpose of supporting members in times of hardship, not to make a profit. Muslims who use such organizations should see their insurance contributions as charitable donations that help their community. Similar to this, Muslims must be aware of whether any financial decisions are made in accordance with these principles.
Another option is for smaller groups to organize their own community-based insurance. This could be the best way to maintain halal practices since members of the group would have complete control over the funds.
Are Insurance Policies Halal or Haram?
This question can be answered with the following: “It depends.” Insurance is considered halal or non-halal depending on the type of insurance offered and the organization it is offered from.
Traditional Islamic scholars will likely consider many modern financial institutions’ insurance products haram.
This does not mean that there is an absolute consensus. From a moral perspective, it is important to note that there is a distinction between buying and selling insurance. It is important to consider the intentions of all parties.
However, some forms of insurance are completely halal. Insurance that is based on fairness, charity, and community support principles has strong biblical support.
This type of insurance is called takaful and Muslims should be comfortable using it to protect their families as well as their neighbors.
You can take control of your financial decisions
You should now be able to understand the debate over whether insurance is halal and haram. Also, you should now be able to understand the key concepts of riba and gharar as well as maysir and takaful.
Perhaps the most important lesson from this discussion is to be mindful when making financial decisions. It’s easy to follow the current flow and ignore the moral consequences of our actions.
We can ensure that our actions and money are fair, responsible, compassionate, and in the best interests of our families, communities, and ourselves.